A comprehensive study recently published in Frontiers in Nutrition aimed to examine the potential connection between tomato consumption, lycopene—the compound responsible for tomatoes’ red color—and cancer risk. The meta-analysis, which reviewed 119 studies and involved nearly 2.7 million participants, found that lycopene intake, rather than tomato consumption alone, could offer protective benefits against cancer.
Background: The Rising Cancer Threat
Cancer incidence and mortality rates continue to rise globally, with an estimated 20 million new cases and nearly 10 million deaths in 2022 alone. This alarming trend is expected to worsen, with projections suggesting that cancer cases will approach 30 million per year by 2040. As the need for preventive measures grows, researchers have increasingly focused on dietary influences, particularly the potential protective effects of fruits and vegetables, which are rich in antioxidants, fiber, and vitamins.
Tomatoes, widely consumed across the world, are rich in lycopene, a carotenoid known for its potent antioxidant properties. While previous studies have suggested that lycopene might help reduce cancer risk, the exact role of lycopene and its bioavailability—how effectively the body can absorb and use it—remains unclear. This is especially true regarding the comparative effects of raw versus processed tomatoes, with cooked or pureed tomatoes often offering more bioavailable lycopene.
Lycopene and Its Role in Cancer Prevention
Lycopene is found not only in tomatoes but also in other red and pink fruits like watermelon and pink grapefruit. However, tomatoes account for over 80% of global human lycopene intake. This study aimed to determine whether lycopene, especially in the form of dietary intake or higher blood levels, is associated with reduced cancer risk and mortality.
The study’s meta-analysis assessed data from four online scientific databases: PubMed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and Web of Science. It examined over 2.6 million participants, reviewing both the relationship between lycopene intake and cancer risk, as well as the potential mortality benefits of higher lycopene blood levels.
Key Findings
The meta-analysis found that higher lycopene consumption was modestly associated with a 5-11% reduction in overall cancer risk. Although tomato consumption alone did not significantly reduce cancer risk, it was linked to an 11% lower cancer-related mortality risk. Additionally, higher blood lycopene levels were associated with reductions in cancer-related deaths ranging from 11% to 24%. The strongest reductions were observed among individuals with higher concentrations of lycopene in their blood, with lung cancer showing the most notable protective effect—a 35% reduction in lung cancer mortality.
While the study found significant benefits from lycopene consumption, particularly from blood levels, it emphasized that tomato intake alone did not appear to provide the same protective effects against cancer. This suggests that lycopene’s role in cancer prevention is more significant than the tomatoes themselves, which contain other compounds that may either support or detract from its potential benefits.
The Specific Cancer Types Affected by Lycopene
The study noted that lycopene consumption had the strongest impact on lung cancer mortality, where higher blood levels of lycopene were associated with a 35% reduction in risk. Breast cancer and prostate cancer also showed some protection, but the evidence for prostate cancer was less conclusive. Interestingly, while dietary lycopene intake showed no significant impact on prostate cancer risk, higher blood lycopene levels did exhibit modest protective associations.
Processed vs. Raw Tomatoes: Bioavailability of Lycopene
Processed tomato products, such as cooked or pureed tomatoes, were found to offer greater bioavailability of lycopene than raw tomatoes. The process of cooking tomatoes increases the release of lycopene, making it easier for the body to absorb and utilize. This insight underscores the importance of including processed tomato products in the diet, especially for individuals seeking to harness the potential cancer-protective effects of lycopene.
Dose-Dependent Effects of Lycopene
The study also examined the optimal amount of lycopene required to achieve these cancer-protective benefits. The dose-dependent evaluation revealed that a daily intake of 5-7 mg of lycopene was associated with the greatest reduction in cancer risk and mortality. However, intakes exceeding 10 mg/day did not appear to offer additional benefits, indicating a plateau effect.
Limitations of the Study
Despite the promising findings, the study authors caution that these results are based on observational data, which cannot establish definitive cause-and-effect relationships. Randomized controlled trials are needed to confirm these associations and clarify whether lycopene directly prevents cancer or merely correlates with lower cancer risks.
Moreover, the study excluded publications that considered the combined effects of tomatoes with other dietary factors, which could potentially confound the results. The researchers note the need for further targeted studies on specific cancers, including endometrial and skin cancers, which were not extensively examined in this review.
Conclusion: Potential for Lycopene in Cancer Prevention
This review and meta-analysis highlights the potential protective role of lycopene in reducing both cancer risk and mortality, particularly when blood lycopene levels are higher. Higher intake of lycopene (5-7 mg/day) was found to be associated with a 5-11% reduction in cancer risk and up to a 24% reduction in cancer-related mortality. The strongest protective effects were observed in lung cancer, where higher blood lycopene levels correlated with a 35% lower risk of death.
These findings support the idea that tomatoes—particularly processed forms that enhance lycopene bioavailability—can play an important role in a cancer-preventive diet. However, the authors emphasize the need for further research to establish a clearer cause-and-effect relationship and to explore the specific role of lycopene in cancer prevention.
As the global cancer burden continues to rise, the identification of simple dietary changes—such as increasing lycopene intake—could serve as a valuable, accessible means of reducing cancer risk and mortality.
You Might Be Interested In:
-
Early Pregnancy Nutrition Impacts Child’s Motor Development at Age 5-6
-
Cooling Treatment Shows No Benefits for Preterm Infants with Hypoxic Ischemic Encephalopathy
-
Frequent Takeaway Food and Low Exercise Levels Linked to Higher Anxiety and Depression
