Scarring is a natural part of the healing process after an injury or surgery. However, for some individuals, scars can become more prominent, thick, or raised, which can lead to aesthetic concerns or even discomfort. Two common types of abnormal scars are keloids and hypertrophic scars. While these two types share similarities in appearance, they have distinct characteristics, causes, and treatment approaches. Understanding the differences between them can help individuals manage their scars more effectively.
What Are Keloids?
Characteristics of Keloid Scars
Keloid scars are raised, thickened areas of fibrous tissue that form at the site of an injury or incision. They grow beyond the boundaries of the original wound, extending into the surrounding healthy skin. Keloids are often red, dark, or hyperpigmented and can be larger than the original wound site. Over time, they can become more pronounced and may even cause discomfort, itching, or pain. In some cases, keloids can grow to a size that is unsightly or obstructive, depending on their location.
Causes of Keloid Scars
The formation of a keloid is largely due to an overproduction of collagen during the healing process. When the body produces too much collagen in response to an injury, the scar tissue becomes raised and spreads beyond the original wound. Genetics play a significant role in keloid formation. People with a family history of keloids are more likely to develop them, especially in response to minor injuries.
Keloids are also more common in people with darker skin tones, including individuals of African, Hispanic, or Asian descent. The exact cause of why some people develop keloids and others do not is not entirely understood, but factors such as skin tension, inflammation, and injury size may contribute to keloid development.
Common Locations for Keloid Scars
Keloids can develop anywhere on the body but are more common on the chest, shoulders, earlobes, and back. They are also frequently found after surgical procedures or piercings, where there is a chance of tension or irritation during healing.
What Are Hypertrophic Scars?
Characteristics of Hypertrophic Scars
Like keloids, hypertrophic scars are raised and thickened scars that form after an injury or surgery. However, the key difference is that hypertrophic scars do not extend beyond the borders of the original wound. These scars are often red, raised, and may be itchy or painful, but they typically shrink or flatten over time. In some cases, hypertrophic scars may take several months to a year to improve in appearance, but they do not continue to grow indefinitely as keloids do.
Causes of Hypertrophic Scars
Hypertrophic scars are also caused by an overproduction of collagen during the healing process, but unlike keloids, the collagen production is contained within the boundaries of the original wound. This leads to a raised, thick scar that remains within the wound site. While hypertrophic scars can form due to trauma, burns, surgical wounds, or other skin injuries, they are more likely to develop in areas of the body where the skin is under tension or is frequently irritated.
In some cases, hypertrophic scars can be related to a genetic predisposition, though they are less commonly inherited than keloids. Skin types that are prone to keloid formation may also be more likely to develop hypertrophic scars. However, unlike keloids, hypertrophic scars are not as persistent or aggressive in their growth.
Common Locations for Hypertrophic Scars
Hypertrophic scars commonly form in areas where the skin experiences regular movement or tension. For instance, they are often found on joints (like elbows or knees), the chest, or other body parts that experience stretching or pulling. Hypertrophic scars can also form after burns or surgical wounds where the skin is under stress as it heals.
Key Differences Between Keloid and Hypertrophic Scars
Growth and Size
One of the most noticeable differences between keloids and hypertrophic scars is their growth. Keloids have a tendency to continue growing well beyond the wound site, often becoming much larger than the original injury. They can even spread into surrounding healthy skin, forming large, irregular masses. Hypertrophic scars, on the other hand, remain confined to the borders of the original wound and do not spread beyond the site. Over time, hypertrophic scars can flatten or shrink on their own, while keloids often remain raised.
Appearance
While both keloids and hypertrophic scars are raised and thickened, keloids are typically more prominent, larger, and may be more rigid in texture. They often have a smooth, shiny surface and can be darker or more pigmented than the surrounding skin. Hypertrophic scars, while also raised and red, are usually smaller and less pronounced, and they tend to fade over time. They are often less noticeable than keloids because they do not spread or grow larger.
Duration of Scar
Keloids are persistent and do not generally improve on their own. Once formed, keloid scars can continue to grow and may require medical intervention for management. In contrast, hypertrophic scars may improve over time without medical treatment. They often soften, flatten, and fade as the body continues to heal, typically within a year. However, hypertrophic scars may still require treatment if they remain painful, itchy, or aesthetically displeasing.
Treatment Options
Treatment for both keloids and hypertrophic scars focuses on reducing the appearance of the scar, alleviating discomfort, and preventing further complications. However, the treatment approach can differ based on the type of scar.
Treatments for Keloid Scars:
Steroid Injections: Steroid injections can help reduce the size and appearance of keloids by decreasing inflammation and collagen production. Multiple injections may be required for optimal results.
Cryotherapy: Cryotherapy involves freezing the keloid with liquid nitrogen to shrink the scar tissue. This treatment is often used for smaller keloids.
Laser Therapy: Laser treatments can help reduce the redness, size, and texture of keloids, though they may require multiple sessions.
Surgical Removal: In some cases, surgical removal of the keloid may be recommended, though there is a risk of the keloid returning after surgery.
Pressure Therapy: Applying pressure to the keloid through specialized garments can help flatten the scar over time.
Treatments for Hypertrophic Scars:
Silicone Gel Sheets: Silicone gel sheets are often recommended for hypertrophic scars, as they can help flatten and fade the scar by hydrating the area and reducing collagen production.
Steroid Injections: Like keloid scars, hypertrophic scars can also benefit from steroid injections to reduce inflammation and minimize the scar’s appearance.
Laser Therapy: Laser treatment may also be used to reduce the redness and thickness of hypertrophic scars, improving their appearance over time.
Massage Therapy: Gently massaging the scar area can help soften and flatten hypertrophic scars as part of a comprehensive treatment plan.
Prevention and Management
While it is not always possible to prevent the formation of abnormal scars, taking steps to care for a wound properly can reduce the risk of developing either keloids or hypertrophic scars. Some general tips for wound care include:
Keeping the wound clean and moisturized.
Avoiding picking or scratching at scabs or healing tissue.
Using sunscreen to protect the scar from UV rays, which can make scars darker or more noticeable.
Seeking medical advice early if you suspect abnormal scarring.
Conclusion
Keloid and hypertrophic scars are both types of abnormal scarring that result from excessive collagen production during the healing process. While they share similarities, including their raised appearance, they differ in size, growth patterns, and how they affect the surrounding skin. Keloids tend to grow beyond the original wound and remain persistent, while hypertrophic scars stay within the wound borders and often fade over time. Understanding these differences is essential for effective treatment and scar management. If you are concerned about scarring, consult with a dermatologist to explore your treatment options.
You Might Be Interested In:
